Seller Investigators is solid. But 25% commission on every dollar recovered adds up fast. Here are your options, from zero-commission scanning to fully done-for-you services.
Full Amazon management plus reimbursement scanning with zero commission. Every dollar Amazon pays back goes to your account. On a $10,000 annual recovery, that's $2,500 you keep vs giving to a 25% commission service. Plus Jarvio handles PPC, inventory, listings, competitors, and reporting.
The most popular reimbursement service on the market. Fully hands-off: they file claims, handle rejections, negotiate with Amazon, and follow up until resolution. 25% commission on all recovered funds. Strong track record with high recovery rates.
Compare with Jarvio →Free reconciliation tool that identifies reimbursement opportunities in your account. Good starting point for sellers who want to see what they might be owed before committing to a paid service or tool. Limited automation beyond identification.
Reimbursement tracking included in their $15/month plan alongside profit analytics, inventory management, and listing change alerts. Basic reimbursement tracking but excellent value if you already use Sellerboard for profitability monitoring.
Compare with Jarvio →Decent reimbursement identification tool included in Helium 10's Diamond plan. More manual work than dedicated services (you still file the claims yourself). Good enough if you already pay for Helium 10 and don't want another subscription.
Compare with Jarvio →Seller Investigators (now part of Carbon6) charges 25% of every dollar recovered. On a $10,000 annual recovery, that's $2,500. On $25,000, that's $6,250. On $50,000, that's $12,500. For sellers with significant reimbursement volume, commission-based services can cost more per year than a full-featured Amazon management platform.
The question every seller should ask: is the convenience of someone else clicking 'submit' in Seller Support worth 25% of your money? The answer depends on your time, your recovery volume, and how comfortable you are filing cases yourself.
With Jarvio, the AI scans your account weekly for discrepancies: lost inventory, damaged inventory, customer return issues, overcharged fees, and weight/dimension errors. It prepares complete claim documentation with transaction IDs, ASINs, quantities, dates, and supporting evidence. You review the prepared claim, copy it into Seller Support, and submit. The entire process takes 5 to 10 minutes per claim. Zero commission.
Reimbursement services like Seller Investigators and GETIDA perform three core functions: scanning your account for discrepancies, preparing documentation for claims, and filing cases with Amazon Seller Support on your behalf.
The scanning and documentation steps are where the real value lies. Identifying discrepancies across thousands of transactions requires systematic comparison of shipment records, inventory adjustments, return reports, and fee calculations. This is complex, time-consuming work when done manually.
The filing step is where the 25% commission becomes questionable. Filing a claim in Seller Support is straightforward: you open a case, paste the documentation, and submit. It takes minutes. The commission model charges you 25% of the recovery for those few minutes of work, on top of the scanning and documentation that a tool can automate.
Jarvio automates the scanning and documentation (the hard parts) and leaves the filing to you (the easy part). You keep 100% of the recovery. For more on this approach, see our reimbursement use case page.
If truly hands-off convenience matters more than cost, GETIDA and Seller Investigators are legitimate options. They handle the entire process including rejections, escalations, and follow-ups. You never log into Seller Support for reimbursement cases. Some sellers value this time savings enough to justify the commission, especially agencies managing many accounts.
If you'd rather keep your money and spend 5 to 10 minutes per claim submitting pre-prepared documentation, Jarvio is the clear winner. The documentation is complete: transaction IDs, evidence, and the specific Amazon policy that supports your claim. You're not doing research or analysis. You're copying and pasting a prepared case.
There's also a middle ground: Sellerboard and Helium 10's Refund Genie identify reimbursement opportunities but provide less documentation than Jarvio. You'll need to do more work preparing the actual claim. These tools are cheaper but require more effort per claim.
Most Amazon sellers are owed money they don't know about. The typical FBA seller has 1-3% of their inventory affected by discrepancies that Amazon should reimburse. For a seller doing $500K in annual revenue, that's $5,000 to $15,000 in potential recoveries.
Common discrepancy types include: inventory lost or damaged in Amazon warehouses, customer returns that were refunded but never returned to your inventory, overcharged FBA fees due to incorrect weight or dimension measurements, and inbound shipment quantity discrepancies.
Amazon has time limits on filing claims (typically 18 months for most categories), so regular scanning is important. Letting discrepancies age beyond the filing window means losing money permanently. Weekly scanning, which Jarvio automates, ensures nothing expires.
For a deeper understanding of the reimbursement landscape, read our guide on whether Amazon owes you money and our detailed FBA reimbursement walkthrough.
If hands-off convenience is your top priority and you're comfortable with 25% commission, GETIDA has the strongest market reputation for done-for-you reimbursement services. Seller Investigators (Carbon6) offers a similar service with a focus on manual case review.
If you want to keep 100% of your recoveries and spend 5 to 10 minutes filing pre-prepared claims, Jarvio is the clear winner. Especially since it also handles PPC automation, inventory monitoring, listing optimization, competitor tracking, and reporting. The reimbursement scanning is included in the subscription at zero additional cost and zero commission.
For sellers who want to understand the direct comparison, our Jarvio vs GETIDA and Jarvio vs Seller Investigators reviews go deeper into the specific differences.
Ready to keep 100% of your reimbursements? Start your free Jarvio trial. Zero commission, ever.
Start free trial